Dog training methods broadly fall into four categories: positive reinforcement (reward-based), clicker training (a specific form of positive reinforcement), balanced training (mix of rewards and corrections), and aversive methods (shock collars, prong collars, alpha rolls). Modern science strongly favors positive reinforcement and clicker training — and major veterinary organizations including AVSAB, AAHA, and APDT have published position statements supporting reward-based methods over aversive ones.
The Training Program We Recommend
Built on positive reinforcement methods. Used by 50,000+ dog owners. Lifetime access.
The dog earns rewards for desired behaviors. The most widely supported method by modern training science. Effective across all breeds and age groups, builds trust between dog and handler, has the lowest risk of creating fear/aggression side effects. Limitations: requires consistency, takes longer to suppress unwanted behaviors than aversive methods (but produces more durable results).
Clicker Training
A specific form of positive reinforcement using a clicker as a precise marker for correct behavior, followed by a reward. The precision of the click bridges the gap between behavior and reward, accelerating learning. Especially effective for fast-learning breeds (Border Collies, Poodles, Australian Shepherds) and for teaching complex behaviors. Anyone can learn clicker training in a few hours.
What to Avoid: Aversive Methods
Shock collars, prong collars, choke chains, alpha rolls, and dominance-based methods are increasingly discredited by training science. Studies consistently show they increase fear, aggression, and reactivity — particularly in working breeds, sensitive breeds, and dogs with any history of trauma. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) explicitly recommends against these methods.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best dog training method?
Positive reinforcement is the consensus best method based on modern training science. It's effective across all breeds, builds trust, and has minimal risk of unintended side effects. Clicker training is a specific form of positive reinforcement that works exceptionally well for fast-learning breeds.
Is positive reinforcement enough for stubborn dogs?
Yes — "stubborn" usually means "not motivated by what you're offering." With high-value rewards (real meat, valued toys), even stubborn breeds (Bulldogs, Beagles, Huskies) respond to positive reinforcement. The challenge is finding the right currency, not increasing punishment.
Are dominance-based methods effective?
Modern training science strongly opposes dominance-based methods. The dominance theory itself has been discredited — wolf pack research from the 1970s that informed it has been retracted by its own authors. Dominance methods often increase the very behaviors they're supposed to fix.
Ready to Start Training?
Step-by-step program with breed-specific guidance and lifetime access.
Disclosure: We earn affiliate commissions when readers buy through some links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial recommendations are independent.
