Stubbornness is mostly a marketing term. The 'stubborn' breeds aren't unintelligent — they're independent, bred for centuries to make decisions on their own (hunting, guarding, sledding, hauling). Compliance with human commands wasn't the point. This guide ranks the 10 most stubborn breeds and explains what training methods actually work for each.
When trainers call a breed stubborn, they mean: low natural motivation to please humans + high motivation to follow their own instincts. The Husky chasing a squirrel isn't ignoring you — they're following 1,000 years of breeding telling them to chase. Working WITH the instinct beats fighting it.
Huskies score #77 in obedience intelligence but are highly capable problem-solvers. They were bred to run independently for hundreds of miles. Off-leash recall is essentially impossible in open environments. Long lines and fences are practical necessities, not training failures. See full Husky training guide →
Beagles have 225 million scent receptors vs humans' 5 million. When they catch a scent, recall commands literally cannot compete with what their brain is processing. Train in low-distraction environments first; use high-value rewards (real meat); accept that off-leash reliability won't transfer to scent-rich areas. See full Beagle training guide →
Bulldogs score #77 in obedience and have low motivation to comply with commands. They're not slow learners — they're deliberate. A new command takes 25-40 repetitions to stick (vs 5 for a Border Collie). Patience plus high-value rewards plus short sessions (5 minutes) is the only path. See full Bulldog training guide →
Step-by-step training program with breed-specific video demos and lifetime access. Used by 50,000+ dog owners.
See the Training ProgramDoxies were bred to hunt badgers underground — independently, without human direction. That trait is baked in. Combine with notoriously slow potty training (4-6 months minimum) and you have one of the more demanding small breeds. See full Dachshund training guide →
Akitas were bred to make decisions alone facing bears. They have minimal genetic motivation to please humans for its own sake. Experienced handlers only. See full Akita training guide →
Malamutes are like Huskies but bigger, stronger, and even more independent. They were bred to haul heavy sleds, not respond to handler commands. Off-leash freedom is unrealistic. See full Alaskan Malamute training guide →
Like other scent hounds, Basset Hounds follow their nose first. Add a low energy level and you have a dog that physically resists when they don't want to walk. Patience and food motivation are essential.
Chow Chows were bred as multi-purpose dogs (guarding, hunting, hauling) and developed strong independence. They bond intensely with one person but can be aloof or even confrontational with others. Early socialization is critical.
Afghan Hounds rank near the bottom of obedience intelligence — but they're sighthounds bred to chase prey at high speed. Training requires accepting their nature: short sessions, high-value rewards, and lure coursing as an outlet.
Shar-Peis were bred as guardian dogs and have strong independence streaks. Like Akitas, they can be aloof with strangers and require careful socialization.
Because they have low natural motivation to please humans for its own sake. Most 'stubborn' breeds were bred to work independently — hunters, guardians, sled dogs. Compliance wasn't selected for. Use high-value rewards and short sessions to get past it.
Yes. Stubborn doesn't mean untrainable — it means motivation matters more than repetition. Find what your specific dog values (real meat, play, weight pull) and use it as currency. Punishment-based methods fail badly with stubborn breeds.
Most are, yes. Bulldogs and Beagles are tolerant of beginner mistakes; Huskies, Malamutes, Akitas, and Shar-Peis are not. First-time owners drawn to these breeds should commit to professional training from puppyhood.
By the metric of low compliance + high independence, it's a tight race between Siberian Huskies, Alaskan Malamutes, and Akitas. Bulldogs and Beagles are stubborn but easier — they at least work for food.
The complete training program covers every breed, every command, every behavior fix.
See the Training ProgramDisclosure: We earn affiliate commissions when readers buy through some links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial recommendations are independent.